Buying players vs Changing the system

I’m going to try and do the impossible today, and that is to try and defend Arsene Wenger and his lack of spending so far this January.

Firstly, I truly hope we do acquire some new signings, and that proven quality arrives in this transfer window. However I do, in some twisted and almost contradictory way, understand Wenger’s reluctance to add to the squad.

The reason is simple: we do have an abundance of quality and skill in the team.

I look through the Arsenal line-up and I see a team of very talented, largely experienced players. I also look at our injury list and find myself amazed at how few crippling injuries we have at the half way stage of the season.

Judging from the team selection so far this season, I’m presuming our first choice eleven is Szczesny, Sagna, Mertesacker, Vermaelen, Gibbs; Arteta, Wilshere, Cazorla; Podolski, Walcott, Giroud.

I look through that team and find it difficult to fault many of the players, or see how they can actively be improved upon.

With the exceptions of Gibbs and Arteta, all of those players are established or important players for their national sides.

I have question marks over Walcott’s attitude and ability, and I think Giroud is still adjusting to both the English game and the role he’s being asked to play, but aside from that there is no obvious weakness in the playing staff.

Furthermore, with players like Koscielny, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Diaby, Rosicky and Ramsey as substitutes, the manager does have options from the bench. (when everyone is fit of course)

However, as much as I look at that line-up and see top quality footballers, the quality on paper isn’t transmitting itself onto the pitch.

I’ve watched some genuinely woeful performances this season, as games vs Norwich, Swansea and Southampton, amongst several others, have passed us by, and wondered how this group of players simply can’t click. I’m sure the manager must do the same.

But in defending Wenger for not spending, it’s also necessary to criticise the manager for allowing the sub-standard performances of his players to occur so frequently.

Is he not motivating them correctly?

Is he selecting unbalanced teams?

Are the tactics we’re playing correct?

I’d defend the manager on the first accusation but I think there are reasonable grounds to argue our system is unbalanced and the tactics deployed are flawed.

I find it hard to believe that a group of elite international footballers, playing under a manager as distinguished and successful as Arsene Wenger, aren’t motivated when playing for Arsenal. It’s a lazy accusation to throw around when things aren’t going well. Look at players like Arteta and Vermaelen; they exude professionalism and competitiveness. I see people question Podolski’s attitude - a guy doesn’t get to 100 Germany caps at 27 years old without being supremely motivated on the pitch. If he continues at his current rate hell break Gerd Muller’s record. His Arsenal stats so far are excellent for a player being played out of position, and in a new league. I can’t wait to see what he produces for us with a full season under his belt.

It’s not Wenger’s fault that a midfield trio of Arteta, Wilshere and Cazorla- all phenomenally gifted footballers – isn’t working. However it is Wenger’s responsibility to acknowledge that the trio isn’t clicking, and to create a solution that does work. Wednesday night vs Swansea saw Cazorla out wide and Wilshere pressed further forward, and maybe that is the first sign that the manager is thinking of adjusting the system.

I’m no tactical expert, and I’m reluctant to criticise the manager’s squad selection, but I have seen enough football matches in my time to know that playing a centre midfielder (Ramsey) as a right attacking forward does nothing to provide balance to a team.

It’s become commonplace to criticise Wenger for his tactical decisions, yet I also feel there is a responsibility of the players to play with a degree of intelligence. For some self-destructive reason, after watching us draw against Southampton on New Year’s Day, I came home and re-watched the match. I couldn’t believe that for the duration of the first hour, with Walcott playing up front on his own, our entire team persisted in looping crosses into the box as our only form of attack. In that time Theo didn’t win a single header. I’m sure we’ve all got our own opinions on Walcott’s strengths and weaknesses, and I concede I’m more harsh on him than most, but even the most basic of footballers must realise that pumping balls into a small forward whose game is based on speed is totally worthless. Yet Arsenal consistently employed the same wasteful tactic.

As soon as Giroud came on, a player who dreams of crosses into the box to utilise his own physical strengths, we abandoned all of our wide play and tried to play everything through the middle, on the floor. It was utterly nonsensical.

These players are all outstanding footballers, I genuinely look at our first eleven and compare it with United and on paper there really is little difference. In actuality, the difference is that United play a system to compliment and accommodate their players, we play a system that requires our players to fit in, which often involves playing in position unfamiliar to them.

So while I would love for us to sign better players, and I do feel that new additions bring more to a team than just on-field improvement, I believe a change in our system to better utilise the players we currently have could be just as beneficial.

------------
If you’ve been having problems accessing this site on your work computer using the URLS globalgooners.com and gossip.globalgooners.com should sort that problem for you.

Get your free LadyArse app here for Android, BlackBerry and Windows phone [iPhone coming soon]

Get your free Arsenal wallpaper, Facebook covers and Twitter headers here

Share

About Lewis

Clock End season ticket holder. Some-time writer. Follow me on Twitter @changearsenal All views are my own.
  • http://www.facebook.com/tony.madders Tony Madders

    I agree that we have a certain level of talent at the club. However, we also are a long ways behind other clubs in some areas.

    Walcott is not big enough or skillful enough to play as a striker. He is also fairly ropey at taking free kicks (I’ll come back to that).

    Comparing Walcott and Giroud to RVP and Rooney or Aguero and Teves and you can see a big gap in my opinion.

    Defensively too, our guys are positionally suspect and poor in the air.

    However, I agree with you that the big issue is tactics. If we played the right tactics, we would be possibly 3-4th (we are not as good as the manc teams).

    Where do we go wrong?

    In the game against Swansea we played far better than I have seen the team play for a long time (possibly all season). The reason was the workrate and the pressing tactics. I cannot understand why we try to emulate Barca offensively, but do not press when not in possession (Barca are brilliant at winning the ball back). So the answer here is to start pressing the opposition all over the field, not just when they come into our half

    We are not direct enough. Every pundit is at pains to tell us that Arsenal like to score the perfect goal. I think what they are really saying is that we are waiting for the perfect run and the perfect pass and until that opportunity presents itself, we are happy to tap it around the midfield and defence. So the answer here is to get the offensive players making runs. I have seen it a number of times when Walcott has been standing on the wing, static, waiting for the ball. He (and the other forwards need to be running into space behind the defence. We need to take some risks in the opposition half.
    We do not have a dead ball taker. We generally do not score from free kicks or corners. RVP had a reputation for this but the statistics do not back this up. He did not score from a free kick for about 5 years for us. Walcott cannot do this either. Its possible that our team is just not tall enough to take advantage, but I reckon that most of our dead balls are wasted. The answer here is to get a recognised free-kick taker in the side

    We are vulnerable at the back, especially due to mistakes (there have been several recently). I do not like the zonal marking system as it gives the opposition a running jump against our static jump. Instead we should be marking tightly, preventing the opposition from running and putting them off. The answer here is coaching, as I actually think our defence is quite good.

    I appreciate that Wenger has much more experience than me at this sort of thing, but when you compare our tactics to others and realise where we fail, it becomes fairly obvious.

    • Lewis

      Thanks for your comments.

      I fully agree I think we look at our best when we play a high pressing game. I actually think Giroud is good at closing the opposition down, and with Wilshere (hopefully) playing further forward from now on I feel his pressing game higher up the field will suit our style.

      I also don’t understand why Theo takes free kicks and corners. Podolski scored an absolute slammer of a free-kick against Southampton at the start of the season and for some reason has barely taken one since.

  • Bum

    I feel like one big problem is an I balance in midfield. Earlier in the season, with Diaby in the team, I thought we had a great balance and it looked like that midfield would be awesome. Since then with Jack and Arteta sitting we’ve looked a bit light weight, we tend to get overrun. Arteta is tactically and position ally very good, his distribution is exemplary but he lacks the meat to be a defensive lynchpin. Jack has so many qualities its joyous but again he lacks that physicality. That’s why Xavi doesn’t hold for Barca or Alonso always plays with Khedira.
    Against Swansea, I thought that was a big difference. Jack was further up the pitch and immense. Behind him both Diaby and Coquelin provided solidity and presence. Particularly in the first half, but even in the second, Arsenal didn’t press too much the emphasis was still more on keeping the shape of the team. But the physicality was different.

    • lewis

      We looked more balanced against Swansea than we have for some time. I’m not going to even consider Diaby as a first team member due to his injury record, but a midfield of Arteta and Coquellin sitting with Jack further forward could certainly give the manager some food for thought.

Categories

The LadyArse Team on Twitter